Beyond the title, this is a serious conversation. Not just a provocative start to peak your interest, but a genuine question. Has this blog, and the now many others, become responsible for killing youthwork?
It would be easy to argue against. I could talk about the many 1000’s of views this blog has had. I could tell you about the feedback I have had whereby volunteers, clergy and workers, managers, supervisors and leaders have provided me, telling me how much benefit this blog has been to them. And I am truly honoured. So, this blog has helped practitioners. It has helped guide and advise. It has provoked a question and provided a reflection.
But has it become a problem ?
Because, if this blog, and the many others, have become the ‘go-to’ for the despairing youth worker, ie a Google search for ‘the role of youths in church ‘
Then what happens to youthwork as a profession as a result?
After all, teaching, medicine and social work haven’t dropped off the pace and become ‘online only’ – though their courses and demand for them to exist.
It was fabulous to receive feedback about this blog 4 weeks ago at a number of conferences. But the truth of what that also means is that whilst I may have influence, the profession is showing signs of rapid decline. There’s only shouting voices left, and this one isn’t going to be taken seriously academically or institutionally.
Blogging cannot shape the discourse of youthwork. It really can’t. But that it is doing so, shows what youth work has left, doesn’t it?
If the books are inaccessible and over priced? (Various recently all over £50)
If books that are accessible are under used?
Not just because of blogging, but why spend £50 on a book, unless you really are a student of the profession, a lifelong student.
It’s far easier to read a review here, or elsewhere and then not bother. So there’s another sale down the drain and license to say ‘Naomi Thompson’s book on Sunday schools talks about x and y and z’ without £80 being invested in the source material, the publisher and giving the profession , the discourse, the impetus it needs.
A profession fuelled on blogs and second hand reviews. Where the academic becomes superfluous. Has gone underground and become a protest movement. Not a serious discourse or profession.
Not that you need to read a book to be a good youth worker. Of course. But that’s not the point . The point is that whilst youthwork might continue in it’s various forms in practice, and blogs supporting them are now numerous, are creative and become almost essential. Their proliferation has by default also indicated the systematic death of the profession. Maybe they haven’t caused it. Maybe kindly it’s being propped up by them.
But a credible profession, which is what youth ministry and youth work, both claim to be, can’t rely on the sugar puff of a blog that’s popular for a week. No one is going to take seriously the future of youth work (in whatever form) if it’s main writers are those who have a moan now and then, and whose work isn’t peer reviewed, published and credible outside of the practice field.
We have to take seriously responsibility for our demise. There’s no advert on tv with a university library youthwork department asking for £3 a month to keep it going. But it is more likely to, if you buy at least 5 youth work books a year. Read them, not (Just) this.
Has this blog killed youthwork? Sadly maybe what it is a symptom of how superfluous youthwork has become. The tide might be turning. But from what kind of discourse of a base. Easier to read a few blogs and go to a conference, than really invest thoroughly in it, and you’d still be a good youth worker that many churches might still employ. Or just get a level 3. And there’s nothing wrong with either.
That’s just where youthwork is.
Killed of by chronic under value and funding. Yet we might ourselves need to look in the mirror and ask where we have been part if it’s downfall. Moan about the high street but still buy on Amazon.
Has this blog killed youthwork? Or just keeping the embers alive…..